I was shocked by the statement of Scott Edwards that, “Drinking water is not a human right … if it costs somebody else money to provide it to you” (“Water Rights,” HCN, 6/24/13). Even the Declaration of Independence states that we are endowed by our “Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and […]
Letter to the editor
Posted inJuly 22, 2013: Red Rock Resolution?
You can’t have your gas and burn it, too
Many Americans are not enthusiastic about drilling in rural areas like the Rocky Mountain Front (“The Rocky Mountain Front blues,” HCN, 6/24/13). Unfortunately, we are also not happy with the cost of energy and our dependence on politically unstable areas such as the Middle East. We want solar power and wind generators, but those also […]
Posted inJune 24, 2013: Water Rights
The grid in the spotlight, where it belongs
I want to thank Jonathan Thompson for his very informative, well-researched and well-written article on the electrical grid (“Haywired,” HCN, 5/27/13). This is certainly a growing problem in this country and one that is not receiving the attention from utility companies and government agencies that it should. I suppose there will have to be some really […]
Posted inJune 24, 2013: Water Rights
Big eyesore on the prairie
The plain fact regarding wind farms is that they are terrible in and for the environment (“Haywired,” HCN, 5/27/13). One day, on a beautiful plateau or prairie, there are small and large game, wild birds of all types and little human interference. The next day, there are large white windmills, roads, fences, people, pickup trucks, neatly groomed pasture, and all the game is gone. A complete […]
Posted inJune 24, 2013: Water Rights
If a tree falls in the forest, who talks about it?
As a fourth-generation Oregonian whose family has only minimally depended on the forest-products industry, I often find myself drifting far from zero-cut environmentalists on the one hand and industry cheerleaders on the other (“A New Forest Paradigm,” HCN, 4/29/13). It’s all too obvious to me how the industry and its dependent towns got into the current […]
Posted inJune 24, 2013: Water Rights
If we build it, rain will come — right?
In the midst of the drought, here in Arizona, the rah-rah development conferences go on, with smooth-talking hucksters claiming that we need to prepare for millions more people who will be moving here (“Dry new world,” HCN, 5/13/13). I’m not sure what will start the inevitable exodus from the Phoenix metro, but the combination of […]
Posted inJune 24, 2013: Water Rights
Saving Alaska from itself
When will it end (“Trouble in the valley of the eagles,” HCN, 5/27/13)? Always more mines, more development, more human impact, less habitat. For every new mine, and new gas or oil well, how about a new protected reserve to mitigate all the “take,” so we humans do not impact every place? Alaska is called […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
A proud, flag-waving liberal
It really annoys me that the American flag has become synonymous with right-wing politics (“Right-wing Migration,” HCN, 5/13/13). I am an avowed “liberal,” as right-wingers derisively call me, yet I grew up with a love for flags. When my parents took me to Denmark as a child to visit the country they grew up in, I immediately […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
An exterminator in land manager’s clothing
As an outdoorsman, environmentalist and hunter I personally find Neil LaRubbio’s notion that Ryan Counts deserves to hunt apex predators because he’s an experienced hunter a stretch (“When predator is prey,” HCN, 5/13/13). I sport fish, but I don’t feel I “deserve” to hunt and kill sharks, and I don’t fish for them. If folks […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
Birds of a (red and blue) feather flock together
I fail to see the point of “Right-wing Migration” (HCN, 5/13/13). I read it looking for evidence of some illegal, fraudulent, immoral or even unexpected behavior and found none. The only “crime” I could discern was that Republicans voted for Republican candidates. Surprise, surprise. It is perfectly understandable that a resident of Southern California would want to emigrate, […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
Choose your political stories wisely
I have read many comments that claim HCN has a liberal bias. “Right-wing Migration” supports that viewpoint because you chose to highlight a place impacted by conservative migration and examined it like it was a negative impact (HCN, 5/13/13). Could HCN also publish a feature article about a place impacted by liberal migration, with a similar takeover […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
Stranger in a strange land
My wife and I moved to Sherwood, Ore., in 2007 to be closer to the grandkids in Portland. We attend the local Catholic Church. Much to my chagrin, the parish is almost solely Republican with an anti-abortion core. For many in the church, there is only one question to ask candidates for public office: “Are […]
Posted inJune 10, 2013: Paradise at a Price
What about race?
One word that was strangely missing from your excellent article on the conservative politics of northern Idaho was “race” (“Right-wing Migration,” HCN, 5/13/13). I have no hard data on this, but I’d guess that the increasing diversity in Southern California is a major reason a lot of right-wingers from Orange County moved to a mostly […]
Posted inMay 27, 2013: Haywired
Of Muir and Pinchot
In “A New Forest Paradigm,” Nathan Rice refers to “John Muir’s preservationist ideals” and “Gifford Pinchot’s utilitarian forestry” (HCN, 4/29/13). Muir certainly fit the mold of a preservationist, believing nature should be preserved for its own sake. But many would argue that Pinchot was more of a traditional conservationist rather than a utilitarian. The latter […]
Posted inMay 27, 2013: Haywired
Saving the real old growth
I read with interest Nathan Rice’s excellent article “A New Forest Paradigm” (HCN, 4/29/13). I was around in the 1970s, when the last of the old-growth giants were being felled in Oregon and Washington. I deplored what was happening then and cheered any means of saving those venerable trees, some of which were over 500 […]
Posted inMay 27, 2013: Haywired
Wanted: Wolves in Colorado
Being an avid elk hunter in Colorado, I hope the trapping and hunting pressure on wolves in Wyoming brings some of them here (“Wolf bycatch,” HCN, 4/29/13). The presence of wolves in Colorado might reduce the number of cattle that overgraze national forest land and ruin the riparian habitat for six months of the year, […]
Posted inMay 27, 2013: Haywired
Word watch
The new buzzword in the woods is “ecological forestry,” to replace “new forestry,” which academics advocated and promoted in the 1990s. I applaud the desire to provide ecosystem management that somewhat mimics nature, but I often question motives (i.e., “to get the cut out”). What “A New Forest Paradigm” fails to acknowledge is that every […]
Posted inMay 13, 2013: Right-wing Migration
California cap and trade’s dirty secret
It is too bad that this otherwise insightful article overlooked a key flaw and dirty secret embodied in the California Air Resources Board’s cap-and-trade law (“A better cap-and-trade?” HCN, 4/15/13). As part of the carbon-trading scheme the ARB launched, the board adopted forest carbon protocols that allow timber companies in California and elsewhere to market […]
Posted inMay 13, 2013: Right-wing Migration
Put the public before profits
If California’s three largest utilities are owned by investors who expect a return (Sacrificial Land, HCN 4/15/13), then we need to devise a way to buy out or replace those investors with public-owned cooperatives. Putting solar panels on rooftops in our cities seems more practical than transporting electricity from remote areas via power lines. I […]
Posted inMay 13, 2013: Right-wing Migration
Sacrifice zones: A regrettable inevitability
I earn my living protecting undeveloped natural ecosystems and restoring degraded landscapes, and I visit Western deserts as frequently as I can. So I sympathize with the residents and stewards of the Mojave Desert confronted by the reality of industrial energy development profiled in Judith Lewis Mernit’s “Sacrificial Land” (HCN, 4/15/13). However, these people’s complaints, […]