Letter to the editor

Dear HCN: Congratulations on your “Grappling with Growth” issue (HCN, 9/5/94). It will circulate around these quarters and be referenced for some time to come. I read Ed Marston’s essay on a possible bust and wanted to respond with some different interpretations. My counterparts in southern Utah see the ups and downs of the California […]

Dear HCN, Blaming federal fire-suppression policy on the conditions leading up to the South Canyon (not Canyon Creek) fire that killed 14 near Glenwood Springs, Colo., is very trendy but bullshit (HCN, 7/25/94). Fuels don’t accumulate in the piûon-juniper vegetative types; typical stands are open-spaced canopies with little understory to carry a fire. In addition, […]

Dear HCN, I read Tom Knudson’s article on Bernard DeVoto with great pleasure (HCN, 8/8/94). Among those who are familiar with his life and writings, DeVoto’s acerbic wit, lifetime commitment to the twin arts of writing and history and passionate defense of both individual liberties and the American West are still inspirational. Yet, his own […]

Dear HCN, Thumbs up on the article “Whose Fault?” in your Aug. 22 issue. It seems that more and more we look toward someone to blame for anything that befalls us. As a skiing and river guide and a former wilderness ranger, I often see people who assume the “invisible someone” out there wouldn’t let […]

Dear HCN, We waited seven years for our permit on the Colorado River. Six months before our launch we started planning: 16 good friends schemed to enjoy the Grand Canyon for 14 days. We each went on this trip for a different reason. Some were there to experience the beauty of the Southwest, some to […]

Dear HCN, Yellowstone Park managers are still not focusing on the main problem – true for most parks, I would guess – and that is crowds and what park officials feel they must do to accommodate them (HCN, 5/30/94). Crowds destroy the basic mood of the park itself – its differentness. This differentness is a […]

Dear HCN, When the U.S. Department of the Interior recently released regulations that would establish procedures for state and local governments to claim road rights-of-way under the old RS 2477 law (HCN, 8/22/94), there was an immediate outcry from Utah’s Sen. Bob Bennett, who said the proposed rules constituted “… a threat to the economy […]

Dear HCN, It was with considerable personal interest I read the article “Forest Service dunked by its own witch hunt” (HCN, 8/8/94) as the mention of Paul Senteney provided a personal link to the national story. As a wildlife biologist for the San Juan National Forest in 1971, Senteney was one of the initial people […]

Dear HCN, I note with particular sympathy the various articles in HCN that talk of the destruction of small Western towns due to the influx of us “city folk.” It reminds me of my early childhood growing up in the Santa Clara Valley, now Silicon Valley, when the majority of land use consisted of orchards […]

Dear HCN, Richard Manning (HCN, 7/25/94) says “a national boycott of gold would make many of our environmental worries go away, as if by magic.” He should carry it even further. What about silver? It is mainly a by-product of other mining, so we could also eliminate copper and other metals to help protect the […]

Dear HCN, Here in my driveway on Carrizo Valley Ranch, I’m sitting on the tailgate of my pickup watching the most vicious forest fire I have ever seen. The entire Patos mountain range is ablaze, producing smoke thermal clouds that can probably be seen from 150 miles away. Flames are visible through the smoke leaping […]

Dear HCN, The reasons the Colorado Outward Bound School is opposed to the Canyonlands Backcountry Management Plan are far greater than group size limits as implied in Florence Williams’ article, “Outdoor Groups Fight Camping Limits’ (HCN, 6/27/94). In fact, the plan proposes to eliminate permits for commercial and educational backpacking groups altogether, thus denying public […]

Dear HCN, Yellowstone National Park faces a terrific dilemma. Enhancement for recreational visitors or management as a diverse ecosystem? What ecosystem? The pre-Columbian system or the modern system which is a result of endless human tinkering? Of course, this kind of dilemma faces not only Yellowstone, but every place. The overriding goal, which researcher Fred […]

Dear HCN, A recent letter criticized Ed Marston’s review of Rangeland Health (HCN, 4/4/94) in which he described range science as “a handmaiden of the livestock industry.” Marston stands accused of political incorrectness for pejoratively using a female gendered word. At least he was civil. Agriculture faculty in the West’s land-grant universities are often accused […]

Dear HCN, It is a sorry thing to read the denigration of men such as Dean Bibles and Ed Hastey, whose long-time public service has been dedicated to protecting public lands under the complicated and confusing rules governing their actions (HCN, 5/16/94). Dean Bibles should be enshrined in the Green Hall of Fame for his […]

Dear HCN, Being an urban dweller, I do not know much personally about grazing, but I do know something about consensus process due to my involvement with co-housing and the Green Party, both of which use consensus process. When it works, its power is inspiring; when it doesn’t, it leads to gridlock. It requires all […]

Dear HCN, One gets the impression that Andy Kerr would like us all to join him in his fundamentalism (HCN, 6/13/94). He tells us the world is divided into discrete units for us to hold in contempt: New Yuppie Scum, Elite Welfare Ranchers, and Old Land Abusers. He tells us they are bad, we are […]

Dear HCN, The issue of grazing on federal lands apparently is no longer a civil debate but, according to Andy Kerr (HCN, 6/13/94), a call to arms, the newest cause of ideological tribalism. The “greens’ versus the “grazers.” Eco-terrorists engaging in actual battle with People For The West. “Us’ against “them,” whoever they are. Polarizing […]

Dear HCN, Todd Wilkinson’s article on neo-Nazis and skinheads (HCN, 6/27/94) resonates in Idaho. This past April, activists from the White Aryan Resistance (WAR) surfaced in Idaho Falls, twice distributing racist leaflets in residential areas of the city. What is interesting about these events is the response of the city, population 45,000, which has tiny […]

Dear HCN, I must respond to the article “Home, home on the range where neo-Nazis and skinheads roam” (HCN, 6/27/94). I am a member of the most discriminated against group in this country – the white male. I am 77 years old and served in combat in Europe during WWII. I did not volunteer to […]