Letter to the editor

Dear HCN, I noticed in a recent article by Elizabeth Manning that the residents of Catron County, N.M., support Dick Manning and his anti-government proclamations (HCN, 10/30/95). As a resident of Catron County I can assure you that is not true. At least half, if not more, of the residents think he is a loud-mouth […]

Dear HCN, Hooray for Tom Casey who wants to preserve the nuclear power plant structures west of Olympia, Wash., according to HCN’s Heard Around the West column Oct. 16. They are an honest representation of our cultural heritage, and, like charming 1800s brick buildings, their presence on the landscape tells us, over time, just where […]

Dear HCN, Ray Ring’s otherwise excellent article about whirling disease and trout in torment (HCN, 9/18/95) missed a critical part of the fisheries picture in the arid West: livestock. One of the key reasons why the Idaho Watersheds Project and eight regional environmental groups filed a listing petition for the desert redband trout with the […]

Dear HCN, High Country News took a cheap shot to deliver a hot opening line in your article about troubles in the Endangered Species Coalition (HCN, 10/16/95). You would get the idea that the National Audubon Society just woke up one day and fired the coalition staff out of pique. Not true. We were forced […]

Dear HCN, As Colorado State Professor John Loomis shows, contingent valuation can be a useful tool to demonstrate how much we value “goods’ like clean air or dam-free rivers (HCN, 9/18/95). Since the valuation we ordinarily look to is that established by parties in mutually beneficial transactions, goods that are not bought and sold may […]

Dear HCN, Regarding the anonymous letter, “Where Credit is Due” (HCN, 10/2/95), I’d like to clarify the litigative history that led to the “saving” of Mono Lake. As the letter correctly noted, the first limitation of water diversions from the Mono Basin was the product of lawsuits filed in 1984 by California Trout. The Mono […]

Dear HCN, I was very pleased to see the article about the efforts of Skip Edwards in the Westwater Wilderness area (HCN, 10/16/95). Our ranch, the Mountain Island Ranch, is the only BLM grazing permittee on the east shore of the Colorado River through the Westwater Canyon. Skip and I have had our differences of […]

Dear HCN, I lived and worked in and near Zion Canyon for 12 years, and during that time the two old pioneer towns at the mouth of the canyon experienced rapidly rising population pressures, both from visitors and new residents. Most of the work available in the canyon entailed contact with a portion of the […]

Dear HCN, I was starting to get bored reading another superficial diatribe – Stephen Lyons’ “Have a Kokopelli Day” (HCN, 9/18/95) – against the new colonizers of the West and indigenous imagery. I perked up, however, at the reference to the picture in the Patagonia catalog of Norbu with his donkeys “laden to the hilt, […]

Dear HCN, I’d like to respond to William Corcoran’s attack on guidebook critics like myself (HCN, 10/2/95). Mr. Corcoran says I should spend more of my energy on Planned Parenthood “instead of preaching perfection to an imperfect world” and in part he’s right. The fact is, there are just too damn many people out there. […]

Dear HCN, Two freshmen Republican members of Don Young’s House Resource Committee from Arizona are working day and night to extend that committee’s endangered species listing moratorium (HCN, 7/24/95). If these men had their way, they would be publishing menus for cooking the endangered Mount Graham red squirrel. Arizona congressmen John Shadegg and J.D. Hayworth […]

Dear HCN, In your Sept. 4 issue, writer Peter Heller was quoted as labeling some of my thinking “the drug dealer defense.” His comment didn’t really make sense, but it had a connotation. With due respect to Peter, I have to say it was a thoughtless analogy. People cannot make sound decisions without good information. […]

Dear HCN, For some reason I am just unable to relate to the long tale of woe of “good” BLM rancher Barbara Cosimati (HCN, 7/24/95). Were it not for socialistic, below-market federal grazing fee subsidies to the West’s Forest Service and BLM ranchers, few of these welfare cowboys could ever compete with our nation’s free-market, […]

Dear HCN, The article on competing water usages for Sierra Vista, Fort Huachuca, and the San Pedro Riparian National Conservation Area opens the door for more general consideration of the dramatic geologic and ecologic changes that have affected the San Pedro River over the past century (HCN, 6/12/95). The paired “before” and “after” pictures (pages […]

Dear HCN, Your essay “How to get rural people to stand proud and tall” perpetuates the myth that the Mono Lake Committee “saved” Mono Lake (HCN, 9/4/95). The record clearly shows that the increased flows into Mono Lake of the past several years – thanks to decreased diversions out of the Mono Basin by the […]

Dear HCN, Thank you for your insightful issue on the ethics of revealing sensitive wilderness locations (HCN, 9/4/95). I have a favorite place in the wilderness: a high mountain lake, right up at the Continental Divide, always half-frozen. The water sparkles there like a million diamonds. The silence is broken only by the sound of […]

Dear HCN, “Fiddling while Rome burns’ should have been the subtitle of Christopher Smith’s stories concerning guidebooks and wilderness usage (HCN, 9/4/95). It’s sad to see wilderness advocates decrying people visiting the Colorado Plateau while the Utah congressional delegation legislates Utah wilderness out of existence. Hiking in the Swell with Steve Allen persuaded me to […]

Dear HCN, Soon, we’ll be deafened by the whining of corporate loggers bemoaning federal Judge Carl Muecke’s recent order halting logging until the Forest Service develops an overall plan in Arizona and New Mexico to save the Mexican spotted owl (HCN, 9/4/95). Why sacrifice the jobs for a little bird, they insist indignantly. First of […]

Dear HCN, Confused by the rhetoric of the “Wise Use” movement? Here’s a handy translation: Like the dinosaurs, it’s a species that just can’t adapt. The species in question can’t leap over dams, thrive on freeways, or make a living in a cow pasture. Playground for Easterners. Any place in the Western United States used […]

Dear HCN, The Esmeralda County Public Lands Advisory Committee is concerned with an article by Karl Hess and Jerry Holechek (HCN, 7/24/95) published in High Country News, because we find that some of your information is exaggerated, misleading or in error. This commission even contacted the BLM and Forest Service with requests to determine from […]