Letter to the editor

Dear HCN, Once a talented surgical team ready to save the world, the environmental movement has devolved into a school nurse dispensing sterile advice and used band-aids. Warning that “time is short,” editor Paul Larmer’s plea for the West as “an island besieged” (HCN, 1/21/02: The American West is an island besieged) presents a brief […]

Dear HCN, First off, I’d like to lavish HCN with praises for putting together such a jolly good read, for sure – then, secondly, for also being well-congealed with quotable info regarding the state of our Western environs … perhaps. Explanation: In his letter of Dec. 3, 2001, regarding Randy Udall’s opinion, “We are the […]

Dear HCN, I realize I’m a little late writing to you about your coalbed methane article (HCN, 11/5/01: Wyoming’s powder keg), but I wanted to provide a viewpoint that probably isn’t shared by many of your readers. What I understand from the article is that some landowners are upset at the development of coalbed methane […]

Dear HCN, We offer the following comments in response to Ed Marston’s cultural critique of our recent book, Post-Cowboy Economics: Pay and Prosperity in the New West (HCN, 12/17/01: Economics with a heart, but no soul). Healthy natural landscapes do not merely provide “playgrounds” and “pretty” amenities for “soulless” in-migrants. They provide a broad range […]

Dear HCN, Jim Downing’s article about the problem of salt in the San Joaquin Valley (HCN, 11/19/01: Will salt sink an agricultural empire?) suggests that, at the present time, the only solution is to complete the aqueduct to the delta. Considering the cost of what is happening now, perhaps one other solution, other than a […]

Dear HCN, I’d like to jump into the ongoing debate over which viewpoints are legitimate for HCN to publish. I understand that this publication was founded with passion for environmental preservation. Very important still, but surely the time is ripe to welcome ranchers and timber companies as potential allies instead of designated villains. I was […]

Dear HCN, I am writing in response to the letter from Courtney White (HCN, 12/3/01: Grazing story ignored radical center), wherein he chastised your paper’s failure to focus on the “radical center” in the public-lands grazing debate. He claimed, “There is a progressive ranching movement afoot, and there are plenty of good stories out there.” […]

Dear HCN, Ray Ring got it mostly right with his dissertation on the relationship of Montana environmentalists with “other” Montanans (HCN, 12/17/01: Bad moon rising). He really nailed it when he got past the “easy” answers and into “rural-thinking, rooted to an immense landscape, and every once in a while rebelling against domination by external […]

Dear HCN, I appreciated Ray Ring’s analysis of Montana’s political landscape. However, I was surprised that he neglected to mention the latest wave of progressive politics in Montana, the Green Party. Montana hosts a statewide Green Party and active groups in Missoula, Bozeman and Billings * that hotbed of radical environmentalism. The Green Party is […]

Dear HCN, As a longtime environmental activist living in Montana and involved in a number of collaborative efforts, I question Mr. Ring’s assumption that it is environmentalists alone who have failed to compromise or work towards shared solutions.After all, it takes two to tango. Looking at the environmental scorecard of Montana Conservation Voters, we see […]

Dear HCN, I believe Ray Ring’s piece on Montana environmental politics lacks a broader contextual framework that would provide insight and result in different conclusions. The suggestion that Montana’s progressive environmental legislation passed in the early 1970s due to greater collaboration with rural industries misses a big historical point. Although briefly acknowledged by Ring, the […]

Dear HCN, Ray Ring’s cover story on the environmental movement in Montana is a fascinating and instructive history which all Western environmentalists should study. But I can’t help feeling Ray missed one of the most important factors in the decline of Montana’s progressive coalition and the environmental movement in the rural West generally. Ring accurately […]

Dear HCN, In the West, water is a pervasive issue, and it is a common theme among HCN articles. “Bringing back the bosque,” and “Will Salt Sink an Agricultural Empire?” (HCN, 11/19/01: Bringing back the bosque) touch this subject. These articles leave one believing that the battle between agriculture and ecological water could never be […]

Ardeth Baxter’s letter commenting on the review of the book Riders of the West requires my response (HCN, 11/19/01: Romanticizing rodeo abuse). Animal-human relationships are the core ingredients in the settlement of the West. That relationship continues in the form of arena events – rodeo, team penning, cutting dressage, etc., and ranch work – gathering, […]

Dear HCN, The Pueblo of Santa Ana sincerely appreciates the extensive coverage in the Nov. 19 issue to highlight our efforts to restore the Rio Grande bosque and river channel within our reservation lands. While we understand that the purpose of the article was to highlight Pueblo efforts, we feel it is important to acknowledge […]

Dear HCN, Thanks for the recent article on coalbed methane (CBM) in the Powder River Basin (HCN, 11/5/01: Wyoming’s powder keg). While some of our issues here in the Raton Basin are slightly different – fewer ranchers, more rural residential development, no celebrity poster child – we appreciate any visibility that CBM development gets. The […]

Dear HCN, I was heartened about the future of our public lands as I read the article on “Global market squeezes sheep ranchers” (HCN, 11/19/01: Global market squeezes sheep ranchers). As a long-term resident of Boise who frequently hikes and mountain bikes on public lands, I have experienced first-hand the effects of Brad Little’s and […]

Dear HCN, Steven Stuebner’s recent article “Global market squeezes sheep ranchers” (HCN, 11/19/01: Global market squeezes sheep ranchers) has to rank as one of HCN‘s worst articles of the year, or silliest. What might have been an informative report on the situation of the sheep industry, if only Stuebner would do a little research, turns […]

Dear HCN, I would like to register a firm objection to the recent cover story, “Healing the Gila” (HCN, 10/22/01: Healing the Gila). I was distressed by its old-fashioned, polemical, “Good Guy vs. Bad Guy” tone, which seems out of character with recent cover stories in HCN. You’ve done a very good job recently covering […]

Dear HCN, In his rush to support environmental activists and ignorance of ecological processes, Tony Davis unwittingly reveals two major fallacies of the anti-grazing movement (HCN, 10/22/01: Healing the Gila). The first involves ecological site potential and the misconception that all you have to do is take the cows off and stand back. “It will […]