Rich Fairbanks can be proud of the work he did in
opting for 96 million board-feet to be cut on the Biscuit salvage
(HCN, 5/16/05: Unsalvageable). The claim by OSU’s John
Sessions that 2.5 billion board-feet could be salvaged was
ludicrous. The regional Washington office estimate that 518 million
board-feet could be salvaged was also unrealistic. Even the final
scaled-back 372 million board-feet target would be unattainable.
The Forest Service remains committed to avoiding tracking
the receipts, cost and net from its timber sales, although it has
all of the facts needed to easily do so.
The
Siskiyou’s average 13-year cut was only 20,841 million
board-feet. It might have expected to ramp the cut up to 96 million
board-feet over a three-year salvage effort.
Attaining
the projected 124 million board-feet over three years was very
unlikely. The Siskiyou’s 13-year timber cash-flow record,
1992-2004, shows a loss of $28.4 million. That’s a loss of
$1,286 per acre logged. For 2004, the loss was $916 per acre. The
more salvage the Siskiyou tried to market, the greater the loss and
the lower would be the stumpage price paid by timber companies. So
far, the numbers for 2005 are looking even worse.
Genuine
fiscal prudence would pay real dividends.
Robert
E. Wolf
Fellow, Society of American Foresters
St. Leonard, Maryland
This article appeared in the print edition of the magazine with the headline Biscuit Salvage is a losing proposition.
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.
